第四纪冰川遗迹的判别标准与方法问题——兼论蒙山巨砾堆积堤之成因

doi:10.7522/j.issn.1000-0240.2017.0143

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 判断中国东部中低山地冰川作用遗迹的真伪，只能通过科学实践检验和学术争鸣加以解决。利用实地考察所测数据资料，证明山东蒙山确无第四纪冰川遗迹。包括蒙山在内的山东中低山丘陵，迄今为止没有发现符合判别标准的末次冰期冰川地貌三要素组合。蒙山兰溪峡谷的谷形指数（0.07~0.24）与世界各地真正的冰川槽谷不符，被当作冰川证据的蒙山兰溪峡谷谷壁擦痕和拦马墙巨砾堆积堤砾石擦痕，不具有作为冰川地貌证据的唯一性或专属性，而是砾石沿河谷滚动、拖拽摩擦和撞击的结果。不连续、不对称分布于兰溪下游凹岸的拦马墙巨砾堆积堤，沿流向延伸或呈流线构造，具有平行主流的平顶、陡坡砾石堆和立石等景观，砾石的圆度、分选和砾组构造均指向泥石流堆积堤或特大洪水巨石边滩。它可能是1668年7月25日郯城大地震保存下来的群发性灾害遗迹。

关键词: 冰川地貌, 三要素组合, 非冰蚀擦痕, 巨砾堆积堤, 山洪泥石流, 蒙山

Abstract: The authenticity of glacial relics in the middle-low mountainous areas, eastern China, could only be discriminated through scientific practice and academic contention. Field measured data proves no Quaternary glacial relic exists in Mount Mengshan. Furthermore, the middle-low mountainous areas in Shandong Province where Mount Mengshan locates has found no last glacial geomorphic assemblage so far, which should contain three elements of glacial erosional landform, glacial depositional landform, and glaciofluvial depositional landform. The form ratio of Lanxi Valley in Mount Mengshan, from 0.07 to 0.24, do not match the real U-shaped valleys' around the world. The scratches on the Lanxi Valley wall and the Lanmaqiang boulder-piled levee, which are considered as evidence of glacier presence, are not of uniqueness and exclusiveness. They are the result of gravel rolling, dragging, rubbing and striking along the valley. The Lanmaqiang boulder-piled levee, distributed intermittently and asymmetrically in the downstream concave bank extending downflow or linearly arranged, has landscapes of flattops paralleled to the mainstream as well as steep gravel piles and standing stones. The roundness, sorting, and fabric of gravels in the levee all point to its origin that is the boulder levee of debris-flow or the boulder-strewn bed of catastrophic flooding. The boulder-piled levee probably is the relic of group disaster caused by the Tancheng Great Earthquake on July 25, 1668.

Key words: glacial landform, three elements assemblage, non-glaciogenic scratches, boulder-piled levee, flash floods and debris flows, Mount Mengshan

中图分类号:

P534.63

王乃昂, 戴霜, 张律吕, 余莺潇, 于昕冉, 田璐, 尹丽颖. 第四纪冰川遗迹的判别标准与方法问题——兼论蒙山巨砾堆积堤之成因[J]. 冰川冻土, 2017, 39(6): 1289-1297.

WANG Nai'ang, DAI Shuang, ZHANG Lülü, YU Yingxiao, YU Xinran, TIAN Lu, YIN Liying. Issues on criteria and methods for discriminating Quaternary glacial relics: also on the origin of the boulder-piled levees in Mount Mengshan[J]. JOURNAL OF GLACIOLOGY AND GEOCRYOLOGY, 2017, 39(6): 1289-1297.

参考文献

[1] Wang Zhaobo, Bian Qing, Li Dapeng, et al. Discovery of the Quaternary glacial relics in Mount Mengshan, Shandong Province[J]. Geological Review, 2017, 63(1):134-142.[王照波, 卞青, 李大鹏, 等. 山东蒙山第四纪冰川组合遗迹的发现及初步研究[J]. 地质论评, 2017, 63(1):134-142.]
[2] Wang Zhaobo, Zhang Jian, Wang Jiangyue, et al. A study on Quaternary glaciation moraines in Mount Mengshan, Shandong Province with Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL) and comparison of glacier period division[J]. Geological Review, 2017, 63(3):694-702.[王照波, 张剑, 王江月, 等. 山东蒙山第四纪冰川遗迹光释光测年研究及冰期划分与对比[J]. 地质论评, 2017, 63(3):694-702.]
[3] Lee J S (Li Siguang). Quaternary glaciations in the Lushan Area, central China[M]. Nanking (Nanjing):Institute of Geology, Academia Sinica, 1947.[李四光. 冰期之庐山[M]. 南京:国立中央研究院地质研究所, 1947.]
[4] Li Siguang. Moraine and ice water deposition in the northwestern margin of the North China Plain[M]//Professional papers on Quaternary glacial relics in China. Beijing:Science Press, 1964:1-13.[李四光. 华北平原西北缘地区的冰碛和冰水沉积[C]//中国第四纪冰川遗迹研究文集. 北京:科学出版社, 1964:1-13.]
[5] Cui Zhijiu, Yang Chienfu, Liu Gengnian, et al. The Quaternary glaciation of Shesan Mountain in Taiwan and glacial classification in monsoon area[J]. Quaternary International, 2002, 97/98:147-153.
[6] Yang Chienfu. Mountains in Taiwan[M]. Taipei County, Taiwan:Walkers Cultural Enterprises, Ltd., 2010:60-79.[杨建夫. 台湾的山脉[M]. 台湾台北县:远足文化事业股份有限公司, 2010:60-79.]
[7] Svensson H. Is the cross-section of a glacial valley a parabola?[J]. Journal of Glaciology, 1959, 3(25):362-363.
[8] Graf W L. The geomorphology of the glacial valley cross section[J]. Arctic and Alpine Research, 1970, 2(4):303-312.
[9] Harbor J M. A discussion of Hirano and Aniya's (1988, 1989) explanation of glacial valley cross profile development[J]. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 1990, 15:369-377.
[10] Harbor J M. Numerical modelling of the development of U-shaped valleys by glacial erosion[J]. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 1992, 104:1364-1375.
[11] Benn D I, Evans D J A. Glaciers and glaciation[M]. 2nd ed. London:Hodder Education, 2010:305-311.
[12] Liu Shuzhen, Liu Xinmin, Zhao Yongtao, et al. Geomorphology and its development of Gongga mountainous region[M]//Geographic expedition in Gongga Mountains. Chongqing:Chongqing Branch of Scientific and Technology Document Press, 1983:21-34.[刘淑珍, 刘新民, 赵永涛, 等. 贡嘎山地区地貌特征及地貌发育史[M]//贡嘎山地理考察. 重庆:科学技术文献出版社重庆分社, 1983:21-34.]
[13] Rea B. Glacial landforms, erosional features:micro to macro scale forms[M]//Encyclopedia of Quaternary science. Amsterdam, the Netherlands:Elsevier, 2007:853-864.
[14] Li Jijun. On glacier striation[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 1982, 4(1):29-34.[李吉均. 论冰川擦痕[J]. 冰川冻土, 1982, 4(1):29-34.]
[15] Gary M, McAfee R, Jr, Wolf C L. Glossary of geology[M]. Washington, D.C.:American Geological Institute, 1972:120.
[16] Susan M. Oxford dictionary of geography[M]. Shanghai:Shanghai Foreign Language Education Press, 2001:73.
[17] Benn D I, Evans D J A. Glaciers and glaciation[M]. 2nd ed. London:Hodder Education, 2010:268-272.
[18] Bussert R. Exhumed erosional landforms of the late Palaeozoic glaciation in northern Ethiopia:indicators of ice-flow direction, palaeolandscape and regional ice dynamics[J]. Gondwana Research, 2010, 18(2):356-369.
[19] Krabbendam M, Bradwell T, Everest J D, et al. Joint-bounded crescentic scars formed by subglacial clast-bed contact forces:implications for bedrock failure beneath glaciers[J]. Geomorphology, 2017, 290:114-127.
[20] Aleinikoff J N, Muhs D R, Bettis E A, et al. Isotopic evidence for the diversity of late Quaternary loess in Nebraska:glaciogenic and nonglaciogenic sources[J]. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 2008, 120(11/12):1362-1377.
[21] Cui Zhijiu. Diamicton and environment[M]. Shijiazhuang:Hebei Science and Technology Press, 2013.[崔之久. 混杂堆积与环境[M]. 石家庄:河北科学技术出版社, 2013.]
[22] Shi Yafeng, Cui Zhijiu, Su Zhen. The Quaternary glaciations and environmental variations in China[M]. Shijiazhuang:Hebei Science and Technology Press, 2006.[施雅风, 崔之久, 苏珍. 中国第四纪冰川与环境变化[M]. 石家庄:河北科学技术出版社, 2006.]
[23] Li Jijun, Zhou Shangzhe. What glacier is the "ultra-maritime glacier":a discussion with Professor Jing Cairui[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2018, 40(1):1-6.[李吉均, 周尚哲. 极海洋型冰川是什么冰川:与景才瑞先生商榷[J]. 冰川冻土, 2018, 40(1):1-6.]
[24] Shi Yafeng, Cui Zhijiu, Li Jijun, et al. Problems on Quaternary glaciation and environments in eastern China[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 1989.[施雅风, 崔之久, 李吉均, 等. 中国东部第四纪冰川与环境问题[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 1989.]
[25] Shi Yafeng, Zhao Jingdong, Wang Jie. New understanding of Quaternary glaciation in China[M]. Shanghai:Shanghai Popular Science Press, 2011.[施雅风, 赵井东, 王杰. 中国第四纪冰川新论[M]. 上海:上海科学普及出版社, 2011.]
[26] Wang Nai'ang, Zhao Jingdong, Yu Yingxiao, et al. The gradually improving scientific research paradigm on Quaternary glaciation in China:a review of the 4th Conference on Quaternary Glaciation and Environmental Variation in China[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2017, 39(5):1029-1038.[王乃昂, 赵井东, 余莺潇, 等. 渐趋完善的第四纪冰川研究范式:记第四届中国第四纪冰川与环境变化研讨会[J]. 冰川冻土, 2017, 39(5):1029-1038.]