冰碛湖溃决泥石流流量计算方法

doi:10.7522/j.issn.1000-0240.2019.0008

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 冰碛湖溃决泥石流是高山高寒地区一种常见的灾害类型，虽爆发频率低，但造成的危害极大，该类型的泥石流防治是区域开发建设中必须要面对的问题，而流量计算又是其核心问题之一。以西藏地区近100 a以来的冰碛湖溃决实例为基础，探讨了溃口深度的计算方法；以逐渐溃决模型和配方法为基础，分析了冰碛湖溃决泥石流的容重峰值流量与洪峰演进计算方法的适用性与流程；通过案例的对比研究，探讨了计算模型参数率定与误差来源。结果表明：瞬间溃决模型高估了冰碛湖溃决泥石流的峰值流量，泥石流的预测值偏保守；而逐渐溃决模型更接近于冰碛湖溃决的物理机制，在冰川U型谷内，可不考虑泥石流的堵塞作用，泥石流的峰值流量预测值与实测值较吻合；在冰川U型谷外或近沟口段则需考虑泥石流的堵塞作用。文中提出的计算模型作为冰碛湖溃决泥石流防治工程参数设计的依据是可行的。

关键词: 冰碛湖溃决, 泥石流流量, 逐渐溃决模型, 米堆沟

Abstract: The debris flow induced by moraine-dammed lake outburst, characterized by low frequency as well as incredible perniciousness, is one of the common geo-hazards in alpine regions with vulnerable environment. Challenges of hazard mitigation, especially the key issues with discharge design, have to be dealt with in the process of regional development and construction. Based on case studies of moraine dammed lakes in the recent 100 years in Tibet, the variation of breach depth of terminal moraine-dammed dam is analyzed; on the basis of gradual breach model and flood-deposition mixture method, computing methods and procedures for unit weight, peak discharge and flood routing of debris flow mobilized by moraine-dammed lake outburst flood are discussed herein. The parameter calibrations and error sources of various computing models are discussed by means of comparative study among relative cases. It is indicated that the gradual outburst model typically overestimate the peak discharges of debris flow and the predicted parameters tend to be conservative; the gradual outburst model, however, substantially coincide with the physical mechanisms of moraine-dammed lake outburst; the predicted peak discharges of debris flow surging in the U shape gully, in which the plugging effect could be negligible, are in line with field investigation by and large. However, the plugging effect could be significant and can not be negligible outside the U shape gully or near the channel mouth. Therefore, the method put forward herein is generally feasible for parameter designs of debris flow control project.

Key words: outburst of moraine-dammed lake, discharge of debris flow, gradual outburst model, Midui Gully

中图分类号:

P642.23

党超, 褚娜娜, 张鹏. 冰碛湖溃决泥石流流量计算方法[J]. 冰川冻土, 2019, 41(1): 165-174.

DANG Chao, CHU Nana, ZHANG Peng. Computing method for discharges of debris flow induced by moraine-dammed lake outburst[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2019, 41(1): 165-174.

参考文献

[1] Clague J J, Evans, S G. A review of catastrophic drainage of moraine-dammed lakes in British Columbia[J]. Quaternary Science Reviews, 2000, 19(17):1763-1783.
[2] Chen Chujun, Liu Ming, Zhang Zhi. Outburst conditions of moraine-dammed lakes and their flood estimation in the headwaters of the Nianchu River, Tibet[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 1996, 18(4):347-352.[陈储军, 刘明, 张帜. 西藏年楚河冰川终碛湖溃决条件及洪水估算[J]. 冰川冻土, 1996, 18(4):347-352.]
[3] Zhang Shuping, Zhang Hucai, Chen Guangjie, et al. Climate and glacier changes and lake response in the Ngangla Ringsto catchment in western Tibetan Plateau[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2012, 34(2):267-276.[张淑萍, 张虎才, 陈光杰, 等. 1973-2010年青藏高原西部昂拉仁错流域气候、冰川变化与湖泊相应[J]. 冰川冻土, 2012, 34(2):267-276.]
[4] Che Tao, Jin Rui, Li Xin, et al. Glacial lakes variation and the potentially dangerous glacial lakes in the Pumqu basin of Tibet during the last two decades[J].[车涛, 晋锐, 李新, 等. 近20 a来西藏朋曲流域冰湖变化及潜在溃决冰湖分析[J]. 冰川冻土, 2004, 26(4):397-402.]
[5] Chen Xiaoqing, Cui Peng, Yang Zhong, et al. Change in glaciers and glacier lakes in Boiqu River basin, middle Himalayas during last 15 years[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2005, 27(6):743-800.[陈晓清, 崔鹏, 杨忠, 等. 近15 a喜玛拉雅山中段波曲流域冰川和冰湖变化[J]. 冰川冻土, 2005, 27(6):743-800.]
[6] Cheng Zunlan, Shi Liang, Liu Jiankang, et al. Distribution and change of glacier lakes in the upper Palongzangbu River[J]. Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation, 2012, 32(5):8-12.[程尊兰, 时亮, 刘建康, 等. 帕隆藏布江上游冰湖分布及其变化[J]. 水土保持通报, 2012, 32(5):8-12.]
[7] Deng Yangxin. Process of accumulation and characteristics of glacial debris flow deposits transformed by moraine[J]. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica, 2005, 13(4):37-48.[邓养鑫. 冰碛转化为冰川泥石流堆积过程及其沉积特征[J]. 沉积学报, 2005, 13(4):37-48.]
[8] Xu Daoming. Dangerous glacial lake and outburst features in Xizang Himalayas[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 1989, 44(5):343-352.[徐道明. 西藏喜马拉雅山区危险性冰湖及溃决特征[J]. 地理学报, 1989, 44(5):343-352.]
[9] Liu Wei. Preliminary study on debris flow induced by glacier lake outburst in Tibet[J]. Hydrogeology & Engineering Geology, 2006, 33(3):88-92.[刘伟. 西藏典型冰湖溃决型泥石流的初步研究[J]. 水文地质与工程地质, 2006, 33(3):88-92.]
[10] Dang Chao. The mechanics of debris flows resulting from glacier lake outburst floods (GLOFs) in southeast Tibet[D]. Chengdu:University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2009.[党超. 藏东南冰湖溃决泥石流形成机制[D]. 成都:中国科学院研究生院, 2009.]
[11] Cui Peng, Ma Dongtao, Chen Ningsheng, et al. The initiation, motion and mitigation of debris flow caused by glacial lake outburst[J]. Quaternary Sciences, 2003, 23(6):621-627.[崔鹏, 马东涛, 陈宁生, 等. 冰湖溃决泥石流的形成、演化与减灾对策[J]. 第四纪研究, 2003, 23(6):621-627.]
[12] Costa J E, Schuster R I. The formation and failure of natural dams[J]. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 1988, 100(7):1054-1068.
[13] L Ruren, Tang Bangxing, Zhu Pingyi. Debris flow and environment in Tibet[M]. Chengdu:Scientific and Technical Document Publishing House, 1999:266-273.[吕儒仁, 唐邦兴, 朱平一. 西藏泥石流与环境[M]. 成都:成都科技大学出版社, 1999:266-273.]
[14] Richardson S D, Reynolds J M. An overview of glacial hazards in the Himalayas[J]. Quaternary International, 2000, 65(99):31-47.
[15] Luo Defu, Mao Jizhou. Mountain hazards and countermeasures along south Sichuan-Tibet Highway in Tibet[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 1995:182-183.[罗德富, 毛济周. 川藏公路南线(西藏境内)山地灾害及防治对策[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 1995:182-183.]
[16] Tuffuell L. Glacial hazards[M]. London:Longman, 1984:12-13.
[17] Chiarle M, Iannotti S, Mortara G, et al. Recent debris flow occurrences associated with glaciers in the Alps[J]. Global and Planetary Change, 2007, 56(1):123-136.
[18] Wang Xin, Liu Shiyin, Ding Yongjian. Study on evaluation method and application of glacial lake outburst flood in Chinese Himalayan region[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 2016:39-40.[王欣, 刘时银, 丁永建. 中国喜马拉雅山冰碛湖溃决灾害评价方法与应用研究[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 2016:39-40.]
[19] Dang Chao, Chu Nana, Ding Yu. The critical condition for the formation of debris flow induced by glacial lake outburst flood[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2014, 36(5):1176-1183.[党超, 褚娜娜, 丁瑜. 冰湖溃决泥石流形成的临界条件[J]. 冰川冻土, 2014, 36(5):1176-1183.]
[20] Jiang Xiangang. Analysis on the formation process of outburst debris flow[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering, 2018, 27(Suppl 1):3613-3622.[蒋先刚. 溃决型泥石流形成过程分析[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报, 2018, 37(增刊1):3613-3622.]
[21] Rickenmann D, Zimmermann M. The 1987 debris flows in Switzerland:documentation and analysis[J]. Geomorphology, 1993, 8(2/3):175-189.
[22] Jakob M. A size classification for debris flows[J]. Engineering Geo1ogy, 2005, 79(3/4):151-161.
[23] Li Deji, You Yong. Bursting of the Midui moraine lake in Bomi, Xizang[J]. Mountain Research, 1992, 10(4):219-224.[李德基, 游勇. 西藏波密米堆冰湖溃决浅议[J]. 山地研究, 1992, 10(4):219-224.]
[24] Zhu Pingyi, He Ziwen, Wang Yangchun. Study on typical mountain hazard along Sichuan-Tibet highway[M]. Chengdu:Scientific and Technical Document Publishing House, 1999:35-52.[朱平一, 何子文, 汪阳春. 川藏公路典型山地灾害研究[M]. 成都:成都科技大学出版社, 1999:35-52.]
[25] Chen Xiaoqing, Chen Ningsheng, Cui Peng. Calculation of discharge of debris flow induced by glacier lake outburst[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2004, 26(3):357-362.[陈晓清, 陈宁生, 崔鹏. 冰川终碛湖溃决泥石流流量计算[J]. 冰川冻土, 2004, 26(3):357-362.]
[26] Jiang Zhongxin, Cui Peng, Jiang Liangwei. Critical hydrologic condition for overflow burst of moraine lake[J]. Journal of Railway Engineering Society, 2004, 84(4):21-26.[蒋忠信, 崔鹏, 蒋良潍. 冰碛湖漫溢型溃决临界水文条件[J]. 铁道工程学报, 2004, 84(4):21-26.]
[27] Walder J S, Costa J E. Outflow floods from glacier-dammed lakes:the effect of mode of lake drainage on flood magnitude[J]. Earth Surface Processes & Landforms, 1996, 21(8):701-723.
[28] Walder J S. Methods for predicting peak discharge of floods caused by failure of natural and constructed earthen dams[J]. Water Resources Research, 1997, 33(10):2337-2348.
[29] Wang Xin, Liu Shiyin. An overview of researches on moraine-dammed lake outburst floods hazards[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2007, 29(4):626-635.[王欣, 刘时银. 冰碛湖溃决灾害研究进展[J]. 冰川冻土, 2007, 29(4):626-635.]
[30] Wahl T L. Uncertainty of predictions of embankment dam breach parameters[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2004, 30(5):389-397.
[31] Dang Chao, Chu Nana, Ding Yu. Predictive uncertainty of peak outflow relations for landslides dam breach[J]. Environmental Earth Sciences, 2014, 72(11):4265-4271.
[32] Fread D L. The NWS DAMBRK model:theoretical background/user documentation[M]. Hydrologic Research Laboratory, National Weather Service, NOAA, 1988.
[33] Dang Chao, Ding Yu, Chu Nana. Simulation of debris dams breach due to overtopping[J]. Mountain Research, 2012, 33(2):207-215.[党超, 丁瑜, 褚娜娜. 土石坝漫顶溃决模型[J]. 山地学报, 2012, 33(2):207-215.]
[34] Fread D L. BREACH, an erosion model for earthen dam failures[M]. Hydrologic Research Laboratory, National Weather Service, NOAA, 1988.
[35] Singh V P, Scarlatos P D. Breach erosion of earth fill dams and flood routing:BEED model[J]. Army Research Office, Battelle, North Carolina, United States, 1985.
[36] Wu Xiaochuan. On the numerical simulation of the process of dam break and flood flow propagation[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing Hydraulic Research Institute, 2004.[吴小川. 溃坝过程及洪水波演进数值模拟研究[D]. 南京:南京水利科学研究院, 2004.]
[37] Liu Jingjing, Cheng Zunlan, Li Yong, et al. A study of the outburst form of the end-moraine lake in Tibet[J]. Earth Science Frontiers, 2009, 16(4):372-380.[刘晶晶, 程尊兰, 李泳, 等. 西藏终碛湖溃决形式研究[J]. 地学前缘, 2009, 16(4):372-380.]
[38] Huang Jinhui, Liu Jiankang, Cheng Zunlan, et al. An experiment of the effects of waves on glacial lake outburst induced by waves overtopping[J]. Mountain Research, 2014, 32(2):241-248.[黄金辉, 刘建康, 程尊兰, 等. 涌浪规模对冰碛湖溃决的影响实验[J]. 山地学报, 2014, 32(2):241-248.]
[39] Awal R, Nakagawa H, Kawaike K, et al. Study on moraine dam failure and resulting flood/debris flow hydrograph due to waves overtopping and erosion[C]//Proceedings of the International Conference on Debris-Flow Hazards Mitigation:Mechanics, Prediction, and Assessment, Padua, Italy. 2011:14-17.
[40] Yamada T. Glacier lakes and their outburst floods in the Nepal Himalaya[R]. Report of Water and Energy Commission Secretariat (WECS), Kathmandu, Nepal, 1993.
[41] Liu Ning, Zhang Jianxin, Lin Wei, et al. Spillway excavation project and dam break flood routing process in Tangjiashan blocked dam resulting from Wenchuan Earthquake[J]. Science in China:Series E Technological Sciences, 2009, 39(8):1359-1366.[刘宁, 张建新, 林伟, 等. 汶川地震唐家山堰塞引流除险工程及溃坝洪水演进过程[J]. 中国科学:E辑技术科学, 2009, 39(8):1359-1366.]
[42] Cheng Zunlan, Zhu Pingyi, Gong Yiwen. Typical debris flow triggered by ice-lake break[J]. Mountain Research, 2003, 21(6):716-720.[程尊兰, 朱平一, 宫怡文. 典型冰湖溃决型泥石流形成机制分析[J]. 山地学报, 2003, 21(6):716-720.]
[43] Liu Jingjing, Tang Chuan, Cheng Zunlan, et al. Impact of temperature on glacier-lake outbursts in Tibet[J]. Journal of Jilin University:Earth Science Edition, 2011, 41(4):1121-1129.[刘晶晶, 唐川, 程尊兰, 等. 气温对西藏冰湖溃决事件的影响[J]. 吉林大学学报(地球科学版), 2011, 41(4):1121-1129.]
[44] Sun Meiping, Liu Shiyin, Yao Xiaojun, e. al. The cause and potential hazard of glacial lake outburst flood occurred on July 5, 2013 in Jiali County, Tibet[J]. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 2014, 36(1):158-165.[孙美平, 刘时银, 姚晓军, 等. 2013年西藏嘉黎县7·5冰湖溃决洪水成因及潜在危害[J]. 冰川冻土, 2014, 36(1):158-165.]
[45] Xie Renzhi. Hydraulics of dam breach[M]. Jinan:Shandong Science & Technology Press, 1993:99-151.[谢任之. 溃坝水力学[M]. 济南:山东科技出版社, 1993:99-151.]
[46] Li Wei. Manual for hydraulic calculation[M]. Beijing:China Water & Power Press, 2006:434-436.[李炜. 水力计算手册[M]. 北京:中国水利水电出版社, 2006:434-436.]
[47] Li Honglian, Cai Xiangxing. The glacial debris flow of China[J]. Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation, 1989, 9(6):1-9.[李鸿琏, 蔡祥兴. 中国冰川泥石流的一些特征[J]. 水土保持通报, 1989, 9(6):1-9.]
[48] Yu Bing. Research on the calculating density by the deposit of debris flows[J]. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica, 2008, 26(5):789-796.[余斌. 根据泥石流沉积物计算泥石流容重的方法研究[J]. 沉积学报, 2008, 26(5):789-796.]
[49] Li Peiji, Liang Dalan. The unit weight and computing method of debris flow[J]. Journal of Sediment Research, 1982, 3:75-83.[李培基, 梁大兰. 泥石流容重及其计算[J]. 泥沙研究, 1982(3):75-83.]
[50] Du Ronghuan, Kang Zhicheng, Chen Xunqian, et al. Debris flow research in the Xiaojiang River basin:a review and perspective[M]. Chongqing:Science and Technique Press at Chongqing Division, 1987:94-103.[杜榕桓, 康志成, 陈循谦, 等. 云南小江泥石流综合考察与防治规划研究[M]. 重庆:科学技术文献出版社重庆分社, 1987:94-103.]
[51] Liu Chaohai, Mayor M R, Shama C K, et al. Report on first expedition to glaciers and glacier lakes in the Pumqu (Arun) and Peiqu (Bhote-Sun Kosi) River Basins, Xizang (Tibet)[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 1988:37-67.
[52] Kang Zhicheng, Li Zhuofen, Ma Ainai, et al. Study on debris flow in China[M]. Beijing:Science Press, 2004:214-215.[康志成, 李焯芬, 马蔼乃, 等. 中国泥石流研究[M]. 北京:科学出版社, 2004:214-215.]
[53] Kang Zhicheng, Zhang Jun. Study and calculation of peak discharge of debris flow[J]. Soil and Water Conservation in China, 1991, 107(2):15-18.[康志成, 张军. 泥石流洪峰流量的研究与计算[J]. 中国水土保持, 1991, 107(2):15-18.]
[54] You Yong, Cheng Zunlan. Modeling experiment of debris flow in Midui Gully, Tibet[J]. Mountain Research, 2005, 23(3):288-293.[游勇, 程尊兰. 西藏波密米堆沟泥石流堵河模型试验[J]. 山地学报, 2005, 23(3):288-293.]
[55] Wu Jishan, Cheng Zunlan, Geng Xueyong. Formation of dam from debris flow in the southeast Tibet[J]. Mountain Research, 2005, 23(4):399-405.[吴积善, 程尊兰, 耿学勇. 西藏东南部泥石流堵塞坝形成机理[J]. 山地学报, 2005, 23(4):399-405.]
[56] Dang Chao, Cui Peng, Cheng Zunlan. The formation and failure of debris flow-dams:backgrounds, key factors and model tests[J]. Environmental Geology, 2009, 57(8):1901-1910.
[57] Dang Chao, Chu Nana. Experimental study on evolution of debris flow induced by moraine lake outburst floods[J]. Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation, 2015, 35(4):29-33.[党超, 褚娜娜. 冰碛湖溃决型泥石流演化过程试验研究[J]. 水土保持通报, 2015, 35(4):29-33.]